Tales of the Parodyverse >> View Post
·
Post By
Scott

Location: Southwest US
Member Since: Sun Sep 02, 2007
Posts: 326
In Reply To
HH

Subj: Didn't see this before I posted...
Posted: Sat May 14, 2011 at 11:56:30 am EDT (Viewed 661 times)
Reply Subj: Re: A Novel Problem
Posted: Tue May 10, 2011 at 04:26:18 am EDT (Viewed 5 times)

Previous Post


    Quote:

    Ian:



    Quote:
    I can't help you on English law, but if you have a question about U.S. intellectual property law, I may be able to provide some advice--but not on an open board. E-mail me.
    JJJ


That's kind but for now I'm going to concentrate on writing the story as time allows. I still write primarily for my own satisfaction, as a release from other stresses of work and life. It's nice that sometimes people have wanted to publish things I've written but that's not why I write.

If I don't finish the story, or if it turns out not to be very good, it'll never see the light of day anyhow.

Beyond that, if a publisher did decide to put it out there then its his editor's problem to determine what if any changes would need to be made to address any conflicts or concerns.

It's not unusual for a publisher to ask for a revised last draft based upon legal advice. Sometimes it's as simple as changing a fictional company's name or not quoting a copyrighted song (you have no idea how much trouble I had to go to to find a suitable big oil corportation name that wasn't already taken in fact or fiction). Other times it's a bit more fundamental, and that's where the dialogue between writer and publisher gets interesting.

On wider issues:

I know a few folks on the board have been advised that they need to keep a distance between themselves and "fan fiction" or to avoid other online writers' work to avoid charged of plagiarism, or to remove older online writing that might not "be up to scratch".

I've had a couple of editors try that on me too. My general view is that if they pay me a huge generous advance I'll think about making radical changes to my life and way or operating. Since so far all my royalties have been based on post-sales income that hasn't been an issue.

Besides, the line between online fiction and published fiction narrows every time someone buys a kindle. If a writer has to avoid other writers' work he'll never read another book in his life. And while I think I probably have improved as a writer over the last decade or so I'm not going to be ashamed of the fact I've worked hard to made those improvements in the only way any writer improves - by writing. So all those damn publishers and editors can get off my lawn.



>I know a few folks on the board have been advised that they need to keep a distance between themselves and "fan fiction" or to avoid other online writers' work to avoid charged of plagiarism, or to remove older online writing that might not "be up to scratch".


Yeah... that would be me. \:\)

>I've had a couple of editors try that on me too. My general view is that if they pay me a huge generous advance I'll think about making radical changes to my life and way or operating. Since so far all my royalties have been based on post-sales income that hasn't been an issue.

>Besides, the line between online fiction and published fiction narrows every time someone buys a kindle. If a writer has to avoid other writers' work he'll never read another book in his life. And while I think I probably have improved as a writer over the last decade or so I'm not going to be ashamed of the fact I've worked hard to made those improvements in the only way any writer improves - by writing. So all those damn publishers and editors can get off my lawn.


Very true! I like this point of view. Thanks. I read others work all the time for my critique group. I also read for enjoyment.
Maybe I should stop being ashamed of my PV work and embrace it?






Scott NIGHT CHILDREN: THE BLOG. Come see!
Posted with Microsoft Internet Explorer 8 4.0; on Windows 7
On Topic™ © 2003-2024 Powermad Software
Copyright © 2003-2024 by Powermad Software